Cameron is sixteen and wants to become a marine biologist. He moved from the United States to the Tampere area at the end of 2020, aged eleven, and finished ninth grade in Valkeakoski this spring. According to his mother, he had no preparatory year. His Finnish lessons were mostly online Wordwall games and a simple book, and in grades six to eight his tests were given in English. In ninth grade everything switched to Finnish, and his grades suffered. His teachers told the family that his options for further education in Finnish were limited, and his school still rated his Finnish as beginner level. His mother has been paying for Finnish classes at adult education centres to close the gap.
This autumn, six cities launched English-language upper secondary programmes, and the family saw them as the obvious next step. But according to Yle, a student must have lived in Finland for less than three years, and Cameron missed the cut-off. The law allows an exception for weighty reasons. Yet a senior adviser at the Ministry of Education and Culture told Yle that he is not aware of it ever being used, and the ministry’s legal specialist said a narrow interpretation is justified. The ministry says admissions are for the schools to decide, while Tampere says the ministry told it the rule cannot be bypassed.
Meanwhile Cameron is in TUVA, a preparatory programme for upper secondary studies, where the other students are adults. His mother says it does not let him improve his final grades, as the family had understood it would. He is also doing a work placement at a nursery where his younger sibling is one of the children.
It is hard to read this without sympathy. On the family’s account, a child has been let down somewhere between 2020 and 2026, and the question is where.
The failure came earlier than upper secondary school
By the family’s account, the failure was in basic education. The government proposal behind the English track (HE 159/2024) sets out a clear principle: basic education should give pupils the qualifications and prerequisites to continue to Finnish or Swedish upper secondary school (lukio), however much of it was studied in another language. If the family is right, Cameron’s case is an example of that principle failing in practice. The school declined to comment on his situation, so we hear only one side. But the pattern he describes is a pupil left to study mostly on his own and then expected to cope in a language he had barely practised in conversation.
An English-language upper secondary school would let him bypass that problem rather than solve it. Students in the track must still pass a Finnish or Swedish second-language exam, but they would do their studies in English. His mother says the family is staying: “This is home. We’re rooted here now.” For a family that has put down roots, strong Finnish is one of the keys that open the door.
Should a pupil move up without the skills?
One place where the problem might have been caught is the decision to move a pupil up a year. Finnish law allows a pupil to repeat a year when, despite support, the objectives have not been reached in one or more subjects, and the Government calls this a last-resort pedagogical solution. Legislation approved in 2026 also allows it on the basis of general school performance, decided jointly by the pupil’s teachers and the head teacher. The article does not say whether it was ever considered for Cameron. My view is that when the language skills needed for the next stage are missing, moving a pupil up unchanged only postpones the problem to a point where there is less time to solve it. Repeating a year helps only if the teaching improves, because otherwise the same gap is simply repeated.
Why the national languages matter
2026 is the Year of the Domestic Languages, named by Education Minister Anders Adlercreutz, who has said that language is irreplaceable for individuals and society and that our domestic languages must be kept alive. Leena Nissilä, director of Kotus, the Institute for the Languages of Finland, has added that the languages of Finland help build identity and participation in Finnish society.
Finnish and Swedish are the national languages under section 17 of the Constitution. The government proposal treats national-language school education as something English provision must not threaten. It also explains that upper secondary studies require adopting Finnish culture, history and ways of working, which the matriculation examination measures, and that is why candidates in the English track must take Finnish or Swedish as a second language. The same logic applies more widely: language and the society it belongs to are learnt together.
Competence in a national language is also built slowly. In a 2015 national evaluation of Finnish as a second language, cited in the proposal, time spent in Finnish school explained pupils’ skills better than anything else. Pupils who went through the whole of basic education in Finland averaged level B2.1, while those with three to eight years averaged B1.2. Years in the system clearly count. That is why early support matters, and why a late switch into English cannot make up for missed Finnish lessons.
The law also treats both national languages as something to be actively secured. The same proposal reforms upper secondary funding to protect schools whose language of instruction is the minority national language in their municipality.
Why the English track is deliberately narrow
The proposal says the track is meant for people whose Finnish or Swedish is not enough for upper secondary studies, and it sets strictly limited criteria so that English provision does not threaten national-language school education. The reason is spelled out in the proposal itself. The existing International Baccalaureate (IB) track was meant to serve work-related mobility, but in spring 2023 about 83 per cent of the students admitted (522 of 630) held a Finnish basic education certificate. In practice the IB worked as a competitive advantage for strong Finnish and Swedish speakers. The proposal also notes that English-language basic education includes Finnish and Swedish speakers, so an open English track could easily turn into a parallel English path from comprehensive school to matriculation.
The design has several safeguards. Candidates in the English track take Finnish or Swedish as a second language as their mandatory mother-tongue exam, the curriculum follows the national core curriculum, and part of the teaching can be given in Finnish or Swedish, which the proposal presents as supporting integration. The starting point of the matriculation examination remains Finnish or Swedish, and the ministry expects about 200 students a year.
What would help Cameron without opening the gates
These are my suggestions, not proposals found in the sources. First, preparatory instruction in Finnish should be provided and documented from the start, with real conversation practice, so that a child arriving at eleven does not reach ninth grade at beginner level. Second, families should be told clearly whether TUVA can be used to improve final grades, because Cameron’s family understood that it could. Third, the exception for weighty reasons should be used where a municipality demonstrably failed to give support. That keeps the track narrow and still gives the rule a purpose.
Svenska dagen
Every year on 6 November Finland marks Svenska dagen, the Swedish Day. According to the National Agency for Education, the day was first celebrated in 1908, and its purpose today is to respect Finland’s bilingualism and to make the Swedish language and Swedish-speaking cultural heritage visible. It is a fitting moment to remember that the national languages in this debate are two, not one. Cameron’s story is about Finnish, but the question behind it applies to both: whether the school system gives every pupil enough time and teaching to learn the language that opens the door to further study, work and participation in society.
Sources: Yle News, 4 November 2026; HE 159/2024, Finlex; Ministry of Education and Culture; Government, legislation on the guarantee of skills; Parliament, reply EV 103/2026; PeVL 12/2004, Parliament; Kotus, 12 November 2025